Friday, November 13, 2026

The Paradox of Unconditional Love

 Salvation from sin is conditional on repentance. 

Salvation from physical death is conditional on making the covenant of obedience and sacrifice before birth. 

Salvation from spiritual death is conditional on confessing Jesus Christ and being obedient to Him. 

Salvation in any kingdom is dependent on keeping the law of that kingdom. 

If I want anything of the world: food, clothing, toys, money, and so forth, it is all conditional upon my work, earning, giving, doing the will of another so they will pay me for my labor. 

Anything I get is conditional. 

I may get Eternal Life if I am obedient to God, following the path that leads to it. 

The “if” is always there. 

Jesus laid down His life for His friends. (see John 15:13) The condition is to be His friends, to come to Him, believe in Him, obey Him, and to love Him. He loves you unconditionally, but His gifts are all conditional. He suffered for all (D&C 19:16), but only His friends receive all that His suffering purchased. They choose to be His friends -- or not. 

Agency is a real choice. He allows His children to suffer when they choose the path of suffering. He really does let each choose his own path. He still loves them when they reject Him, so when they suffer He suffers with them. He weeps out of sorrow when they suffer. Perhaps “unconditional” doesn’t mean “guaranteed result.” It may mean the opposite: to love unconditionally is to remain bound to someone whatever they choose, which is what makes the lover able to suffer. The one who loves unconditionally paradoxically lets go of the beloved, but remains with them. The beloved is free to choose, and the lover lets him, no matter what he chooses, but still loves him. The lover desires happiness, peace, and joy for his beloved, but is still there when he chooses to leave. It is completely unselfish, unconditional love. He says, in effect: “I have a blueprint for your happiness, but I don’t force it, I love all you are and all you will be. I will stay with you and suffer with you if you make choices that lead there. I will be there.” 

The paradox centers around the lover preparing, working, and suffering for the beloved unconditionally, while those He loves are given the choice to receive these gifts, or not. Love requires freedom, and freedom allows loss. Love that compelled its outcome would not be love. So, the same love that wants the beloved saved must allow him also to be lost.

The lover lets go and yet remains. He releases control completely but does not withdraw his love at all. On the other hand, human love tends to hold on to a fantasy or desire for the other to fill selfish needs and then leave when there is no hope that the beloved will comply. Instead, God supplies a castle with servants and everything anyone could want, but His children refuse, choosing instead to live homeless, "wretched, and miserable, and poor, and blind, and naked" (Revelation 3:17) in the street -- and He goes with them. His compassion is the literal definition of the word: to suffer with. 

The greatest power refuses to use power. The one being who could force the result is the one who won’t, so the Almighty weeps. The idea that He who has all power and owns everything would weep over one who chooses not to partake of His goodness fills me with awe and wonder. “Here’s love and grief beyond degree” (Isaac Watts 1674-1748). It is beyond any love imaginable. Enoch was dumbfounded when he saw God weeping over the people who rejected Him. 

And Enoch said unto the Lord: How is it that thou canst weep, seeing thou art holy, and from all eternity to all eternity? And were it possible that man could number the particles of the earth, yea, millions of earths like this, it would not be a beginning to the number of thy creations; and thy curtains are stretched out still; and yet thou art there, and thy bosom is there; and also thou art just; thou art merciful and kind forever; And thou hast taken Zion to thine own bosom, from all thy creations, from all eternity to all eternity; and naught but peace, justice, and truth is the habitation of thy throne; and mercy shall go before thy face and have no end; how is it thou canst weep? (Moses 7:29-31)

God answers that question in stating that these are His children, He loves them, He gave them agency, allowing them to choose, and wants them to choose Him, but they choose Satan instead. He still loves them. The greater the love, the greater the suffering. Conditional love can protect itself by withdrawing when it is rejected, but unconditional love has no exit and must bear whatever the beloved chooses.

That leaves a hard consequence, which is the greatest paradox. The unrepentant will suffer for sins that have already been suffered for. The price was paid in full and for everyone, and yet it may still go unreceived. The giving was unconditional and universal, the receiving is conditional and particular, and God will not close that gap by force, which is why He weeps.

...Satan shall be their father, and misery shall be their doom; and the whole heavens shall weep over them, even all the workmanship of mine hands; wherefore should not the heavens weep, seeing these shall suffer? (Moses 7:37)

God invites all the workmanship of His hands to take part in His compassion. In the world, we are offered a gift of the love of God, to possess it ourselves. Charity is the pure love of Christ (Moroni 7:47). It is His own unconditional love, given to man as a gift. Like all of His gifts it has a condition: it is bestowed on the true followers of His Son, who pray for it with all the energy of heart (Moroni 7:48). Those who receive it begin to love as He loves. They cannot suffer for the sins of others, as only He could, but they can suffer with them. A parent suffers with a wayward child, not giving him everything he wants, but setting rules and boundaries, and weeping when he refuses them. A spouse continues to love when the marriage is not filling his needs. A friend who chooses a different path is still a friend. Charity “suffereth long” and “endureth all things” (Moroni 7:45). Those who possess it want their beloved to be happy, but they leave him free to choose and do not reject him for his choice. The paradox of charity is that we don’t have continual joy in unconditional love. To receive the gift of charity is to have a heart that can feel joy, but at the same time it inevitably brings sorrow because a heart can be broken. Those who desire the gift of charity must agree to feel the paradoxical extremes of joy and sorrow as God does. 

Monday, November 2, 2026

Love is Diversity

Last week I went to visit my son in Virginia. He and his wife moved three thousand miles away because of work. They own a house and have built a life there with friends, but no family. Alex plays tennis and is one of the better players on his teams. He has leadership positions at work, moving up the corporate ladder. We had a lot of time to talk while driving to a tennis match three hours away that was canceled due to rain. When he was younger, he would have been very upset, but now he took it all in stride. He is in the process of installing a beautiful wood floor in his home, something we did in my house when he was young. He and I also did some work around his house, putting up a lamp, getting some shutters, and fixing a shower valve. He was the craftsman and I was his helper. We had a great time, at least I did. 

I loved him as a child. We called him “cutest man” because even as a baby he looked like a little man. He was intense, focused. He knew what he wanted, and we supplied it. When he was a toddler, I would follow him around and point, “Look how cute he is!” My mom would tell me that I was spoiling him, but I didn’t care. 

As a father, I want my children to become adults. I don’t want them to be children forever. Alex grew up. Though I loved his childhood, I am so happy that we are now peers. He will always be my son, but has become my equal, except, perhaps, in experience. His ways are different. He doesn’t do what I would do. He wants different things. He has his own ideas and opinions about politics, economics, God, and man. He is making his own life. I see that in many ways he is a better man than I was at his age. It’s good to be different, that’s what makes being with him so enjoyable. 

As humans we often appreciate sameness, enjoying people who are like us. We even expect our children to be “a chip off the ol’ block.” And we reject those who think and act differently, creating “us” and “them.” God is just the opposite. He doesn’t love us for our sameness; He loves all the ways that we are different from Him. He wants all to come to Him with their unique talents, abilities, thoughts, and ideas. This is how the love of God is different from that of mankind. If you love differences, and everyone is unique, then you love everyone. 

The creeds describe a God whose love is complete within the Trinity, three Persons sharing one nature, one mind, one will. But that is love of the same. Sameness is merely self-love extended. Love is always directed toward someone else. It takes difference to make love real.  To say God "lacks nothing" is true of His power but not true of His love: a being with infinite capacity to love, and no one to love who is not different from Himself, is a being whose love is never actually fulfilled. 

God has no need to create servants, sycophants, or yes-men. He is omnipotent and omniscient and has no need of anything. But also, God is love, and love must have a beloved. He wants children out of His love. Children who are truly loved are meant to become adults with individual personalities. He wants them to grow up and become His peers — beings who are paradoxically like Him and yet profoundly unlike Him, each adding something to His glory that nothing else could add. Their differences are not a flaw in His creation; they are the very point of it. The God who wanted automatons would still be lonely. 

To fulfill His love, God wants His children to know Him. Each would see Him from a different point, each angle revealing a glory the others cannot. John explained that “...when he shall appear, we shall be like him; for we shall see him as he is.” (1 John 3:2) But “like Him” does not mean a carbon copy, rather it is to have His power, to possess what He has, and to know what He knows. It is to become as God, able “to know good and evil (See Genesis 3:22). To know God is not to be the same, but to love as He loves.

If sameness were a requirement to be in heaven, then Jesus would be the only one there. And this is what Christ came to do: not to be the only One to return, nor to rescue a remnant and leave the rest to burn, but to make possible what God has always wanted — a heaven filled with beings who are not copies of Him, but peers. Each with a face no one else has, adding a glory no one else could. We came to earth to experience evil, but this leaves us unfit to live with God. The need for Christ is that He paid the price to clean us from our sojourn in the dirt of the world. To take advantage of His Atonement, the requirement for salvation is repentance, not to make us the same as Him, but to sacrifice the things of the world and seek Him while retaining our own personality. Because of the atonement of Jesus Christ, heaven will be filled with His children. God is His Father, who becomes our Father -- if we desire. 

God dearly wants everyone but lets them choose, which is the basis of diversity. Though Jesus paid the price for all to be with God, many will not accept His offer. All are given agency to choose to be with God, or not. Jesus said, “Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.” (Matthew 7:14) Few seek the Highest, most are content with a lesser portion. Those few who do find the path of repentance and turn to Christ will be led to the Father and enjoy eternal life with Him. They share His glory, inheriting all that He has. Though it be relatively few of all His creations, God will have some children who grow up to be peers, like their Father. 

My cutest little boy has grown up to become a man. I gave him all I could, and now he makes his own choices. He lives on the opposite coast. He does some things I taught him — flooring, electrical, plumbing, home repairs — and some things he learned from his mother, like tennis. But he has a life I did not plan for him, opinions I didn't give him, a God he has found in his own way. He is not a chip off my block. He is his own block, which may only be colored by mine. And I love him more for it. His unique abilities add to me. My life is greater because he is different from me. If God is anything like a father — and I believe He is — then this is what He wants from all of us: not copies, but children who are grown-up, and independent.